Today's Headlines

Other Sections

News

Corunna School Board removes display on homosexuality

By SEAN ELY, Argus-Press Staff Writer

Monday, October 26, 2009 10:15 AM EDT

CORUNNA - The Corunna Board of Education voted Monday to remove a club project in a display case at Corunna High School that highlighted the acceptance of homosexuality and alternative lifestyles.

The Diversity Club's display featured about nine photos of athletes, politicians and educators who live a homosexual lifestyle, Corunna Superintendent Dr. Mark Miller said.

The 5-2 decision during Monday's meeting sends the sensitive issue to the District Health Advisory Committee so it can be discussed in an open forum in front of the public.

Since the Board of Education met in the middle school building, not everyone could head to the display case and review the group's project.

With numerous parents complaining about it, the Board felt it best to have the project removed from the case - as there are just 10 days left in October.

The committee has training in specific areas dealing with the issue allowing them to delve into greater depth - all open to the public.

“We only had a problem with this specific display,” said Maureen Stanley, president of the Corunna Board of Education. “The club will continue ... it has nothing to do with the club. The specific display, however, has been amended.”

The committee is made up of teachers, ministers, health-field professionals, parents, counselors, school board members and students who discuss topics such as the display case item specifically, at what age to inform students about various lifestyles, where projects may be displayed in the buildings and an overall public comment session.

The meeting will take place within the next two weeks, with a date, time and place posted upon announcement.

This controversial issue of sexual orientation falls under the District Health Advisory Committee, along with other topics such as pregnancy, health education, diversity and abstinence, among other topics.

Stanley said the Diversity Club was created to promote tolerance, respect and discuss how to treat all groups equally recognizing that everyone is different.

The group's October's theme, profiling gay and lesbians, would be better dealt in other scenarios such as in human sexuality or diversity classes, according to members of the board, Stanley said.

“The display case may confuse other kids,” she said. “High school kids can be very impressionable so that might be better dealt with in those classes.”

Stanley said because the display case limits the amount of information given to students, a more informational setting is necessary to discuss the alternative lifestyles.

“We aren't going to review everything that this club does,” Stanley said.

“We did not feel that was something that needed to be highlighted in the school, that's basically it,” Trustee Lyle Brooks said.

Comment on this Story

08 Grad wrote on Dec 8, 2009 12:38 PM:

" Sadly, this doesn't surprise me. When will administration and the school board begin sticking up for people's rights instead of shoving their petty Christian beliefs down others throats? Corunna is so full of ignorant, sheltered people and it seems that the board is proud to continue breeding the idiocy. I'm embarrassed to have graduated from such a school. "

CHS 2003 grad. wrote on Nov 11, 2009 3:10 PM:

" Being a CHS alum...all I have to say is seriously people in 2009 on the verge of 2010?!! Are you really that scared of the Homosexual,bi, and transgendered people? That seeing pictures of sucessful people who are happy with their lives could make you think that "impressionable" CHS students would all abandon the Heterosexual ways? Here is a news flash...there are Gay, Lesbian, bi-sexual and transgendered people in CORUNNA! Some of them even go to high school in your small town. Seeing a picture is not going to make a kid change their sexual orientation. Seriously the CHS school board need to jump into the times....I remember when I went to CHS having a anatomy book that was older than I was because heaven forbid....We see pictures of Naked bodies....nope we had to have the out dated books because they had drawings. You say you support the Diversity Club, but I guess only when they meet your idea of acceptable diversity. But mostly I just want to say you are hindering your students and leaving them unprepared for the world you are sending them into. Not only that but it is exactly this kind of attitude that leads to hate crimes and violence against innocent people...no one wants that not even you. Oh and in case you were wondering...no I AM NOT gay, lesbian, bi-sexual or transgendered myself. So as my Grandfather would say "Put that in your pipe and smoke it" "

livithardcore wrote on Nov 6, 2009 4:50 PM:

" For Anne:

http://www.stoptheaclu.com/2005/06/17/aclu-and-nambla-a-match-made-in-hell/

There's your buddies from the ACLU in action. Do some research moron. "

Crazy wrote on Nov 3, 2009 8:12 AM:

" Wow, this board should have tabled the discussion and then reviewed it before acting so irrational the first time. "

redbeard wrote on Nov 1, 2009 3:36 PM:

" Yeah, First Amendment! No state sponsored religion and free speech guaranteed (even if and especially when, it offends your "moral" sensibilities). "

Henry wrote on Oct 31, 2009 1:43 PM:

" Aren't conservatives supposed to believe in the rule of law?

Freedom of speech and the right to a fair trial must be for everybody, or they are safe for nobody. This is why the ACLU defends scoundrels like NAMBLA, Oliver North, and Rush Limbaugh. "

Anne wrote on Oct 30, 2009 9:25 AM:

" livithardcore wrote: "Everyone should become a member of the ACLU?" Are you serious? I would rather drink a 1/5 of turpentine and piss on a brush fire. The ACLU also defends classic cases like NAMBLA which supports adult men and young boys."

People who fall for internet rumors are not intelligent enough to use the internet... lol.
Never happened. Made up by nutters. "

livithardcore wrote on Oct 29, 2009 5:48 PM:

" "Everyone should become a member of the ACLU?" Are you serious? I would rather drink a 1/5 of turpentine and piss on a brush fire. The ACLU also defends classic cases like NAMBLA which supports adult men and young boys. Sounds like a great organization. Liberals are taking over this country...even in Shiawassee County for pete's sake. I just hope these same liberals who have the everyone-gets-a-ribbon that cry over issues like this will have the guts to step up and defend the same country that gives them our freedom of speech. War? You need me to join? The silence is deafening. "

grad 09 wrote on Oct 29, 2009 5:27 PM:

" I've always believed that CHS coddles their students, and perhaps it's not just CHS; however, since I am a graduate from Corunna, I can only speak for this high school. The administrators, faculty, and PARENTS especially need to realize that right after high school, kids are thrown into the "real world." In the real world, there is a thing called diversity, unlike what little exists in the school district. There are people from all ethnic backgrounds living in this country outside of little Corunna, some who may be mentally handicapped, or who have other differences such as identifying as gay, lesbian, transgendered, etc. We all have differences, and students at Corunna need to be taught that, especially those who are college-bound.
Whoever the parents are who complained about the display case need to wake up and look around. Your child will soon be entering the real world where they'll have to face the diversity of which it contains. If your student is a senior and heading to college next year, go ahead and write a letter to the university asking them to prohibit any public displays dipicting sexual orientation. See how far it gets you! If you know you can't do it next year, then why do it now?
Teach these students that there is a world outside of Corunna. Teach them that there is a thing called diversity. And QUIT sheltering and coddling them. You're causing more harm than good. "

Anne wrote on Oct 29, 2009 1:07 PM:

" Finally! Sanity has prevailed! Thanks CMS Mom, for passing on the good news. "

CMS Mom wrote on Oct 29, 2009 7:50 AM:

" Attention! Would the spelling police please forgive me for hitting the wrong keys sometimes I'll try to do better this time. Well I see that some people are still degrading CHS student. Wake up people they know more then you. Oh! and I just don't sit behind the
computer. I'm giving back to the schools, I clean up the litter left behind from people at the sport events. The kids at the school and all others that can't put litter in is place. My kids are doing the same. I sent this article to a friend to get his take on it. He has helped me with the problems with my son always being called gay. He has sent it to people he knows to look at the. Here are somethings that was sent back to me. I just haven't seen an update on the Argus Press. Read and learn see what else is being said.

From: Dennis Hall
Subject: [LAHRDi] Re: Corunna School Board removes display on homosexuality
To: LAHRDi@yahoogroups.com
Date: Tuesday, October 27, 2009, 9:58 AM

I am pleased to let everyone know that Jay Kaplan, staff attorney with the ACLU-MI's LGBT Project is already involved with this one. He has intereviewed the Principal, some of the students and is preparing a Freedom of Information Request for the audio tape of the school board meeting. This is just one reason why everyone should be a member of the ACLU and supporting its LGBT Project. You can make a donation to the LGBT Project through the ACLU-MI Fund (which is a 501 c3 deductible contribution under the federal income tax) directly on line (as well as become a member of the ACLU) by going to http://www.aclumich .org.
Dennis Hall

From: Douglas Meeks
Sent: Wed, Oct 28, 2009 11:15 am
Subject: Please see below:

ACLU just got off the phone with the Corruna School District and the school board will be rescinding the action that they took last week at the Monday nite, November 2nd school board meeting. The Board realizes that the action they took raises 1st Amendment concerns- when a school district creates an open forum for non-curricular clubs like the display cases, it can censor a display based on its content. The Diversity Club will be permitted to put back their exhibit in the display case.
Thank you for the e-mail. Doug Meeks
Now you should check this web site. the Argus so slow. http://michiganmessenger.com/28947/shiawassee-county-school-district-to-rescind-decision-to-remove-gay-history-month-display. "

ctmajka wrote on Oct 28, 2009 3:04 PM:

" "BIG" Doesn't understand how homosexuality/heterosexuality work...we can forgive him/her for this ignorance. Same goes for the school board. The use of the term "Lifestyle" to describe homosexuality is very misleading. A lifestyle is something that is chosen...ones sexuality is not chosen, it's given. It's all about certain chemicals in the brain is all. Not a disease, not an epidemic, CERTAINLY not a choice. I think the school board needs to realize that this has hurt people, and can make LGBT teens feel unwanted and unaccepted in their school. It wasn't a choice for those teens to be attracted to what they are, but it was a choice for that school board to basically tell them they are a bad influence on the kids. Who should feel more ashamed? "

Gabbyvoice wrote on Oct 27, 2009 11:55 PM:

" Well, i know many LGBT. espcially bisexual single, bisexual couples and bi curious at --Bimingle.com-- . can view the bisexual style photos. hot but also honest girl and cute. "

shame on corunna wrote on Oct 27, 2009 1:50 PM:

" Corunna needs to show more versatality when it comes to sexual orientation. Once you get into college you have to experience it and it doesn't get censored out. From what I hear, the display was just showing gay/lesbian people. This display was not a sex display by any means. What does gay/lesbian always have to be referred to "sex". Its different. "

chs grad wrote on Oct 27, 2009 12:34 PM:

" As usual Corunna Public School drops the ball on this one to. Instead of doing something about the drug and alchol abuse in their lockerrooms they pick on kids that do not have a choice of sexally. O h yeah thats right these kids have big Corunna names from their moms and dads making a big play back in the 1980 s . But the varity football coach found out about these six special names and suspended them for 3 games and gave up a shot at the football play-offs for for this year . That is a man with great honor and dignety to go against that great Corunna tradition of THE NAME GAME . This is the second time this coach as done something like this . He was at a school function for the football team where six names where these students parents either worked for the school system or onthe school board itself , and sent these players home from that function...football varity camp...where they shot a gentman with their paintball guns from one of the school board parents van . By the way ,none and I stress none of these kids wre suspended or even talked to about what they did . Now that is Counna tradition . I called Johnny Smith myself and he said and I quote "Don't worry about unless you give me your name so I can tell the coach you have a problem with a hoax and joke of the matter".that the 6 player did .As usally lift the carpet and sweep under it a another big Corunna tradition. So the coach can tell the coach so he can tell the team that your son has a problem with it , so he can bring my son up in front of the so does not look like a team player.One good thing about that incident that coach resigned at that end of that year . Thats when Coruuna finally hired a coach with strong backbone to stand up to these names and said that is enough. So I will end with this as long as your name is in a past Corunna yearbook and daddy play quarterback or played on the state basketball team your name on the back of the jersey should read ,NOBODY,and as for Johnny Smith has since retired I will say this KARMA will fine that guys family and put them in front of somebody and make a example out of them .So he can see how that taste. I will see to it Smith alll the way to my last dieing breath. Remeber one thing Coruuna School Board you are a elected offfial of the system and one day you will not have a name to back you up whenthe names leave this losing tradition behind . This time it is about sexallity next it will be about skin color mark my words on that. Because the names in Corunna names are not going to let thier kids play back-up to kids of color., wait and see . And I would encourage any other Coruuna parent to write on here and tell about the CORUNNA NAME GAME all you see why people genally don not like Corunna kids. So namers bring it on I have many, many skeletons in the closet that I would love to throw under the bus..Good night now. "

Tony McMillan wrote on Oct 27, 2009 12:32 PM:

" I'm horrified that Stanley actually believes the display case "may confuse other kids". Confused about what exactly? I think this is a obvious first amendment violation and yet another example of intolerace from both the parents and the council. "

shawn wrote on Oct 27, 2009 12:08 PM:

" Geeze, it appears the students are way ahead of the adults on this issue of tolerance. And keep religion out of it. Once these kids leave Corunna and enter the real world they will find diversity and a bigger acceptance of other peoples. Not a very progressive school. But then again, there's never been a gay farmer now has there!?(sic) "

mother fo cms student wrote on Oct 27, 2009 11:43 AM:

" i think that we all need to get along and love each other the way we are it does not matter what side of the fence you are on. maybe the school board school should be contacted by the news and get it all out in the open. the school board should also stop plaing the name game. just love everybody no matter size, color, or who they love "

Anne wrote on Oct 27, 2009 11:33 AM:

" Gary wrote: " Looks like the school board violated the First Amendment rights of members of the Diversity Club. The board is not permitted to censor expressive conduct that it disagrees with. "

Now see, that IS a proper definition of 1st Amendment rights being denied. Well said. "

Corunna mom wrote on Oct 27, 2009 11:30 AM:

" This is a comment to "Big". Seriously, you did not just point out the fact that some of these postings have misspelled words? I can run down a list right now on the numerous words you did not spell correctly in your email. Smarter for one thing is not spelled "smater". That was the funniest one to me. You were saying your children were "smater" than the children that were in the public school system as opposed to your brilliant home schooled children? How about "thier"? That is also misspelled. The word "alot" is technically two seperate words. Just an fyi for your future spelling lessons to your children. "

Agent Junk wrote on Oct 27, 2009 11:13 AM:

" I'm sick of all the stone age, cave man, beer swilling hicks that all of us younger citizens have to share our community with. I'm not a homosexual myself, but I fully support them. As for you poor excuses for parents out there, if children wish to explore that lifestyle then you as parents and guardians need to recognize that you cant FORCE your kids to think or act a certain way. This is a new time people, and the backwards, hateful, and homophobic ways of the past need to end if we are going to move forward. Also, you need to think about censorship in our schools. It starts with a pro- homosexual display in a school hallway, where does it end. I know, how about since the 9/11 attacks on we're so horrible that we don't want kids learning about it, lets just censor that too. How about evolution, or hey how about art, there is nudity in some art so we should censor that too. Pretty soon we're gonna have our kids wearing the same clothes, thinking the same thoughts, and living their lives in a blissful and horrifying ignorance. Whats going to happen when these kids reach the real world, are they going to think that its okay to hate or condemn homosexuals? Are they going to act violently towards someone who is different then they are? A simple little display in a backwater nowhere community isn't going to turn thousands of children in to homosexuals. I think the parents who complained about this really need to get back to worrying about real dangers to their children like the flu, or drunk driving, not some pictures of gay people in a little hallway. "

Have you seen the display wrote on Oct 27, 2009 9:01 AM:

" All of these people commenting on the display and whether it is right or wrong? I have one question for you: "Did you see the display?" I did get to see the display before it was taken down. It was as simple as this: two rainbow flags, a banner that said Gay, Lesbian, Bi-Sexual Awareness Month", and had some pictures of prominent individuals who are gay, lesibian, or bi-sexual. No different than having a display case with prominent African Americans during a month to honor them. "

Nate wrote on Oct 27, 2009 8:54 AM:

" For those referring to Leviticus Chapter 18 Verse 22 as part or, in some short-sighted opinions, all of your case against homosexuality...I have one question for you. I have read enough of the Bible to know a little about this: In Numbers 15:32-36 the Isrealites found a man gathering sticks on the Sabbath. God directed them to stone that man to death for working on the sabbath. Does that mean I should have my boss arrested for working on Saturday or should I kill him myself? Deuteronomy 28:53: If an enemy lays seige to my hometown or country, is it ok for my parents to boil and eat me? Leviticus 24:10-16,23: Yesterday my coworker uttered the words "God d*mnit" after tripping over a chair in the office. Would it be ok to kill him for blasphemy by any means available to me or do I really NEED to use stones?

Seems to me that if you really fear the Lord your God then you would heed his word when he says "read the entire Bible and read it every day." Do I? No. But it seems to me that I'll have to come to grips with that. God didn't tell us to pick and choose but for His sake, there is something called civility in this world that has been a work in progress since before His time... "

Brownie wrote on Oct 27, 2009 7:15 AM:

" To Big...check YOUR spelling...it's 'government'. "

Frankster wrote on Oct 27, 2009 5:03 AM:

" SO if they have a freakish display for the prom aren't they promoting heterosexual lifestyle? Diversity club is to teach tolerance for everyone? Well not just for those who may identity as LGBT. I get the clue that they hate my younger brothers and sisters. Unless the kids are breaking out over sexual stuff leave them alone! For example A picture of rosie odonnel kissing her partner won't hurt the fragile little minds of these children. "

Big wrote on Oct 27, 2009 2:15 AM:

" First of all, alot of you people out there need to go back to school. You need to learn how to spell. Second of all, the gays need thier own island so they can't spread thier diseases. You know, all these strange new goverment controlled diseases that the Nobama administration is killing people off with. With the gays help. Good for the Corunna school. I will always homeschool. My kids know that gays are wrong and my kids are much smater than in the public school system. Most of you should be teaching your kids better morals and desensitizing them when they get home from school. They will become gay or mental down the road. Help them now or pay later. Adam and Eve. Not Adam and Steve. "

Bill wrote on Oct 27, 2009 1:17 AM:

" If you have to do a display on sexuality, why not a heterosexual display. Why do we have to label the display at all. I do not believe that any sexuality needs to be PROMOTED in the school system. It is the job of parents to educate their children on these issues. There are classes and support groups for people that need to talk about these things but not everyone needs to have this pushed under their noses to see. Good Job Board Members. "

Stu Harrison wrote on Oct 27, 2009 1:03 AM:

" Get real people. Here's why your kids need to be educated about gay/lesbian citizens. BECAUSE KEEPING THEM IN IGNORANCE COULD GET THEM PUT IN JAIL FOR LIFE, like these 20 ignorant, violent teenage thugs:

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ukpress/article/ALeqM5jQqTFfxRzUpPc4lXKU-IPBAV3d0Q "

Gary wrote on Oct 27, 2009 12:52 AM:

" Looks like the school board violated the First Amendment rights of members of the Diversity Club. The board is not permitted to censor expressive conduct that it disagrees with. "

Jamie C. wrote on Oct 26, 2009 11:31 PM:

" What is wrong with you people? Not only are you showing these kids that its not ok to be different, but you are also breeding hate.
There are always going to be people that are different, thats how God made us.Are you going to sit here and insue children to hate and do things that might hurt others just because you are scared of someone who is different or loves someone that you might not agree with?
This is rediculous, grow up all of you. This group wanted to teach tolerance and by stopping that, you open the door for bad things to happen and more of a shock when the kids from the small towns go to the big cities and see how things are in the real world.
Again GROW UP!!!! "

livithardcore wrote on Oct 26, 2009 11:14 PM:

" To gladtobegone:

Really? 1 out of 4 kids at CHS are bi? C'mon man, where did you get this info from? That's like saying according to High Times Magazine, 75% of all people smoke pot. I'm sure your daughter will encounter the same issues at any school in the country, not just Corunna. "

Proud to be a school of choice family_Go Corunna wrote on Oct 26, 2009 10:58 PM:

" I have one simple solution: To all of you complaining, do something about it. Don't hide behind your computers, the next time you can, earn your seat on the board...If you're worthy enough and have the time and energy, feel free, it's your right!Get involved with your childs school. Join the PTO, volunteer. My entire family is proud to have our first child in Corunna Public Schools. Our sons Kindergarten teacher Mrs. Boilore is amazing, and the principal Mrs. Sixx-King is the best!! Instead of blogging, I suggest talking...voice your opinion. Look back at the article you're complaining about...read "meeting will take place within the next two weeks, with a date, time and place posted upon announcement" "

Dan wrote on Oct 26, 2009 3:03 PM:

" Why is it so "offensive" for so many christians to even witness the suggestion that 'other' people are humans and have lives as well (many of which are even practicing christians). If you are so insecure that you have to demonize others and even dehumanize children, I would find it unlikely that you are even vaguely confident in your faith and worldview. "

WOW wrote on Oct 26, 2009 1:58 PM:

" All I can say is that if you shelter your children from the realities of the world, they will be ill-prepared to face life's real challenges. "

paul wrote on Oct 26, 2009 1:18 PM:

" Why is it difficult to say something is wrong. We do have right and wrong, good and bad, good and evil. I will not sit here while people shove wrong down my throat. I intend no harm, but I do intend offense. I am offended by this behavior, in addition to many other behaviors that have offended mankind for thousands of years. We are not being more open by this display, we are getting further away from the truth. "

gladtobegone wrote on Oct 26, 2009 1:02 PM:

" First off, there is no God. Second, all primates explore vast variations of sexuality.

I am so glad I moved away from the Corunna School system for the well-being of my gay daughter.

What kind of message is the school board sending to the 1 out of 10 students that are gay and the 1 out of 4 who are bi-sexual who attend the school?

They should be ashamed and if I was still in the area I would lead a protest and demand a recall of the school board members... "

Moe wrote on Oct 26, 2009 1:01 PM:

" Yes, God does say repent and you will be forgiven. Aparently you havent studied much of the Bible. If your in a sudden accident and die befor you repent what then, you can't ask God to forgive you after your dead..Dosen't work that way. You have to have a truthful hear and change your ways. Its not like I'll play the adultry game, but befor I die I'll ask God them to forgive me. This is a very dangerous way to live, No one will stand befor God and enter heaven with sin on them. "

CMS Mom wrote on Oct 26, 2009 8:21 AM:

" I have to children in Corunna School. To think that people think that High School Student minds can't understand gay\lesbian. What their minds are so sallow. What you as a parent do think your children already know about gay\lesbian. I guess their not smart enough to understand. You people need to give your kid a lot more credit. I've talked to my kids. Your so concerned about this issue.What about other in the School. Here think about this one. Why do our Seniors do a Senior project. That time could be used in other ways. They could go and clean the litter that they leave on the school grounds. Check into why this project is so important to your child. You really think that only this is in high school. Well wake up people your kids are saying things in elementary School. I've been dealing with this issue starting in 4th grade. Your kid are saying things to others and they think it great. Now in CMS. Still the problem continues. You parents need to step back and look at your young child. Just because your son\daughter don't do the things that a boy should do or a girl should do. As our society has made our boys\girls to act like a boy or girl if not then your gay\lesbian. The school are already dealing with some kids calling someone gay\lesbian. When my son come home everyday I ask him how was your day. Then I get to ask him if he had any problems with boys calling him gay. My oldest, who was a CHS last year, Has had to stick up for his brother. He has told he friend not to come around any more because he call his brother gay. That is how my son gets to go to school. His day sometime starts off being called gay. The board should think about the CHS student. They aren't dumb. "

former CHS grad wrote on Oct 25, 2009 10:46 PM:

" Did the entire board even look at the display that was presented by the diversity club? My guess in No. When you have 2 board members that are former teachers at CHS from 3 decades ago, 1 board member that was a former employee with an axe to grind, and 2 board members that just want to agree with the majority----CHS is doomed. This whole situation was handled inappropriately in front of the public and should have been further reviewed and discussed. I am assuming the Superintendent and Principal walk the halls of CHS daily and also am assuming they thought the display was tasteful and not influencial. If this is the "new" Corunna School system board of education protocol----guarantee enrollment will be effected. The board is to advise based upon consultation with paid school administrators. This board appears to be trying to run the district as back seat drivers. Never remember prior CHS board from decades before making front page news on controversial issues that are faced and will be faced by our kids every single day in today's environment. Sad times for CHS currently if this new board continues this type of agenda. Also got to agree with Dan Basso on his editorial on the subject on this one--don't also agree with Dan's views but belive he got this one right. "

tired or this.... wrote on Oct 25, 2009 10:01 PM:

" To SB.
The community is confused... Which "committee" will review this topic? The Board voted to discuss this topic by a subcommittee of the Board... "

interested wrote on Oct 25, 2009 2:09 PM:

" Just wondering where Oct. 25 and 26 comments can be found? "

CMS Mom wrote on Oct 25, 2009 11:15 AM:

Miss wrote on Oct 25, 2009 1:38 AM:

" Ok really people do you realize how HATEFUL 90% of you sound? Really? We have become a nation of hate." I hate you bc your gay." " I hate you bc you believe in God" I hate you because you believe in Islam" HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE!

Being a born again believer, I do not condone "alternative" life styles but that is not the point. Our schools should be about reading, writing and arithmetic( as M posted). Yes it is a time in your life where you discover who you are and make some life decisions. But if the school is going to do it's best to keep God out of schools, then all of the other stuff shouldn't matter either. But the fact of the matter is as long as there are tests, sporting events, and difficult classes to take- kids will be praying. As long as there are people who chose ( yes chose, they have found that homosexuality IS NOT proven to be genetic- read up) to enjoy the company of the same gender in a way that was not intended, then they will do it. But to FORCE me or my kids to accept it is a contradiction because you will not accept my life style choice. For one, it should be the parents job to talk to their kids about life as we all know it- not the school and sure as heck isn't the governments place to tell me how to tell my kids either.
As for those that quote the bible to support your sin- shame on you. God is love, and He calls those who believe in Him and trust in Him to "love your neighbor as our selves", not accept your neighbors' life style choices.
TY CPS for doing your best to keep it all bipartisan. And not choosing one or the other. "

LJL wrote on Oct 24, 2009 8:10 PM:

" God loves us all, we are all sinners, when you believe in god and ask for forgiveness with good intentions our heavenly father will forgive. We god loving, fearing people will only be guided by the holy bible and gods wisdom.We do not like to think were religious but that we have a personnal relationship with our Heavenly father. We are not to judge for those who judge will be judged. "

oops wrote on Oct 24, 2009 3:58 PM:

" I posted using the name Moe--I meant it to be replying to Moe! "

Moe wrote on Oct 24, 2009 3:57 PM:

" But if one repents and asks for forgiveness, one is forgiven.

Don't forget that part!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Moe wrote on Oct 24, 2009 12:55 AM:
" JK If you want to qoute the Bible, don't just do the parts you like. Its all or none. God says for a man not to lay with another man nor a woman another woman, this is an abomanation to God and you will burn in Hell.(He said it , I didn't) I for one believe the Bible to be the truth. He hasn't changed his mind so I suggest you take it up with HIM.I don't support the gay and lesbian groups, and I don't accept them. Love them yes, their sin NO. "

SB wrote on Oct 24, 2009 1:27 PM:

" Strange, the arguments made by these writers who oppose the Corunna Board's decision, who criticize the comments made(and allegedly made. . .) by some of its members, and who cry "intolerance" and "free speech violation."
- By telling the Board members to, in effect, "keep your opinions to yourself," is that not violating their free speech??
- By not supporting their decision to pass this along to the proper committee and removing the display in the meantime, is that not being intolerant towards them??
Funny how "free speech" and "intolerance" can so often be self-serving. I grant you "free speech" (but only if your speech pleases me). I expect you to show tolerance (but if you aren't so in the way I wish, I will not tolerate it). "

chsgrad wrote on Oct 24, 2009 1:27 PM:

" I am a graduate of CHS and after reading this article it makes my heart sink to think that I used to be a Cavalier. The world is SOOOO much bigger than Corunna, there are so many different people and religions and lifestyles in this world and I think that these kids have a right to know about it! As far as being worried about "confusing the children"...seriously? Kids are trying to figure out who they are in high school! If a child realizes they are gay or lesbian why should they be made to feel bad about it? I understand that being gay/lesbian is not how GOD intended people to be...BUT there are...you can't sweep them under the rug and deal with it later. When I went to college I felt socially intimidated because I was suddenly faced with different races, cultures and sexual orientations. There is a very big "small town" mentality in Corunna. This can be a breath of fresh air...until it comes to diversity. If you want to prepare children for the real world you need to do more than just make them book smart. "

CJ wrote on Oct 24, 2009 12:50 PM:

" I assume all of you who say that the bible tells us that homosexuality is wrong also follow every other directive held within the good book? Do you kill your disrespectful children? Do you work on the Sabbath? Do you refrain from wearing clothing made of more than one kind of material?

You can't pick and choose what you want to follow based on your own ignorance and hatred.

Why don't you try to do something good and kind to honor your god and religion, instead of spreading hate and intolerance? Jesus would be ashamed of how you dishonor him. "

Taxpayer wrote on Oct 24, 2009 11:53 AM:

" The slippery slope Dan Basso predicted has started. First the library, now the schools. Where does the right to limit other's speech stop? I'm not necessarily pro-gay rights, but that doesn't sound like the purpose of the display. Instead of taking it down, encourage the club to also present alternative viewpoints. "

Freedom wrote on Oct 24, 2009 12:56 AM:

" It is a very sad day when so many people rise up against a group because they are different. For thoes who say homosexuality is a choise it isn't it is genetic. Besides for all of you who say it's a crime against god, he has no say, it is a matter of the first ammendment. You people need to understand that hiding these things and shunning them because they are not your beliefs is doing alot more harm than good. If someone wanted to make a poster of god or christianity and others wanted it down people would be up in arms, but why not now? God loves everyone not just the truly "religous" if thats what you even want to call them. "

Moe wrote on Oct 24, 2009 12:55 AM:

" JK If you want to qoute the Bible, don't just do the parts you like. Its all or none. God says for a man not to lay with another man nor a woman another woman, this is an abomanation to God and you will burn in Hell.(He said it , I didn't) I for one believe the Bible to be the truth. He hasn't changed his mind so I suggest you take it up with HIM.I don't support the gay and lesbian groups, and I don't accept them. Love them yes, their sin NO. As for Corunna Schools You Rock, still the best local school in Shiawassee county. Thank You "

Frank S. wrote on Oct 23, 2009 11:24 PM:

" There is diversity in this world. This world is bigger than the walls of Corunna High School.
Loving people accept diversity. Please expand your minds to love and accept all. Please let the diversity group continue. Please get informed and educate yourself. Homosexuality is not a disease that can be spread. It is a a small group of people that can be embraced. "

Ann wrote on Oct 23, 2009 10:10 PM:

" This is insane. I think that I should probably remove my child from Corunna Schools before high school. She will face these kinds of issues when she goes to college. Address them now and talk about them, the only conversation you will get after high shcool is what weekend they are coming home to do laundry. This is reality people, and for those of you who fail to recognize the world around you...wake up, this is the real world and your child will enter it. Yes, even if you try to shelter them and keep them in the Corunna bubble. "

A parent wrote on Oct 23, 2009 8:58 PM:

" Parents have every right to make complaints, offer suggestions, and control the schools in which their children are enrolled. In Germany, all the schools are controlled by the government and parents have no say in what is taught or any other aspect of campus life. Teachers, students, and administrators are accountable to the parents of the children they teach and not the other way around. This has nothing to do with tolerance or intolerance, but has everything to do with what parents want for their children. In addition, one is not intolerant just because he is opposed to your views. The push these days is for acceptance not tolerance. By the way, I have several friends who live as homosexuals. They know from the get-go that I do not agree with their life style and that I won't change that view since my life is not based on mine or their opinions about homosexuality. We have remained friends, believe it or not. There will be a judgment one day and I certainly won't be the judge since I, too, will be judged. But, know that there will be a judgment and we all will be held accountable before a just judge whose "opinion" does count. "

4pets wrote on Oct 23, 2009 8:32 PM:

" Hate the sin not the sinner. I applaud the parents who stood up and complained about a bulliten board message that promotes odd sex! Yes homosexual sex is odd- it is not how the human body was designed to "function". Oh sure there may be a very very low percentage of folks out there who when they were born they were equipped with both sets of genitalia and the parents had to decide which ones to keep and perhaps they made the wrong pick- that is the only type of case that makes sense when it comes to odd sex choices. Oh I know you gays are going to get all mad- but if I went out and tried to push any other type of odd sex onto your kids, like, it's ok to love a horse or duck or sheep or whatever cause that is your "orientation" then I am sure you would find that disturbing and if not then you really are messed up! "

shiataxpayer wrote on Oct 23, 2009 7:53 PM:

" Small minds rule in small towns.

So afraid that homosexuality is like a virus--you will "catch it" if you acknowledge it.

Well, guess what--your children go to school with, sit next to, study with, talk with, eat lunch with, play sports with, and befriend, homosexuals.

You think 9 pictures are going to confuse your child so now those pictures are taken down and tucked away--back in the closet, so to speak.

Now, it you can just get rid of all those gays in the school your kids will be safe.

So sad. Intolerance reigns supreme.

Those kids who have learned one thing--acceptance as defined by the adults doesn't include them if they are homosexual.

A shameful day for Corunna School district. "

JD wrote on Oct 23, 2009 7:49 PM:

" Wow! This is the first time I have ever said that I am ashamed to have my children attend Corunna Public Schools. I saw the "display case". It was really a bulletin board that was quite tastefully done. Shame on Mr. Lockwood for using his elected position to showcase his religious beliefs. I thought there was supposed to be a seperation of church and state in public schools. I believe it is time for me to get a school of choice form and send my children to Owosso where they are openminded and treat all people as equal. Thank you Mr. Lockwood for making my choice easier. "

LL wrote on Oct 23, 2009 6:04 PM:

" This article makes me very happy that I moved my child out of this environment. I do not want my children educated by a group of people who are anything but accepting of this worlds diverse group of citizens. Each child, each person should be able to sing from the roof-tops who they are without any fear or guilt but pride and respect for themselves and their world.

I'm ashamed of the Corunna school board. The town seems as closed minded and backwards as I remember.

Its really very sad. "

you cant see me wrote on Oct 23, 2009 5:38 PM:

" Way to go school board Gay is not the way!! It goes Adam and Eve not Adam and Steve!! "

Michael wrote on Oct 23, 2009 5:29 PM:

" This is BS. Corunna blows. Your kids live too much of a sheltered life. "

JK wrote on Oct 23, 2009 4:55 PM:

" Wow, its nice to know the bigots and homophobes still live in Corunna. Let's not put up displays in school where you can have an educated discussion about it. I feel really bad for those kids at Corunna who are gay/lesbian or might just be figuring out that they are now and are forced to hide it because of the example the school board has set. By forcing the display to come down they are pushing kids back into the closet, essentially putting them down and making them believe they're bad kids.

It's funny a very popular show I'm sure many high schooler watch "Grey's anatomy" just had a little discussion on this. a gay female doctor is confronted by her father about her sexuality. Her father was spouting bible quotes about homosexuality being evil, this was her response: Jesus.. a new commandment that I give unto you that you love one another. Jesus.. He who is without sin among you let him cast the first stone. Blessed are the merciful for they shall obtain mercy. Jesus.. Blessed are the pure and heart for they see God. Jesus…blessed are those who have been persecuted for righteousness sake for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven. Jesus is my savior Daddy not you, and Jesus would be ashamed of you for judging me, He would be ashamed of you for turning your back on me, He would be ashamed…."

Maybe those in the community need to take a lesson from a TV show and learn that all people need love and tolerance and to save judgement for God, I'm sure he has way more experience than you do. "

be fair to all wrote on Oct 23, 2009 4:55 PM:

" Oh come on! You know if something Chirstian would have been put up, you all would have a fit and wanted the same thing done, if not more! Way to go to the school board. Don't be pushed around! "

js wrote on Oct 23, 2009 4:40 PM:

" Will this area EVER come out of the dark ages?? I was born and raised in this area, and I haven't seen a whole lot of changes in how the people around here think. How often are the parents even in the school? Doesn't the display fall under the guidelines of Freedom of Speech??

'“The display case may confuse other kids,” she said. “High school kids can be very impressionable so that might be better dealt with in those classes.”' This is a quote printed in this Article by Maureen Stanley. Does she really think that a display is going to make students turn into homosexuals? That's what it sounds like. I'm glad that my child has graduated and isn't in a school where the President of the Corunna Board of Education, and the parents, act like moronic bigots. "

James Eaton wrote on Oct 23, 2009 4:21 PM:

" What a sad day when Corunna Schools cannot stand up for the dignity and worth of all people. "

Anne wrote on Oct 23, 2009 4:18 PM:

" Found them...

http://www.argus-press.com/articles/2009/10/22/news/news2.txt#blogcomments

Combine the 2, and you get a community where most prefer diversity. Thankfully most of our citizens have an IQ over 80... "

Anne wrote on Oct 23, 2009 4:08 PM:

" WHAT HAPPENED TO ALL THE OTHER COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE? "

M wrote on Oct 23, 2009 3:39 PM:

" School use to be about reading, riting, and rithmetic. Why should school be a place where our children should be taught a lifestyle we don't endorse. Pratice what you want outside the classroom. "

livithardcore wrote on Oct 23, 2009 3:38 PM:

" Corunna did the right thing here. Do not compare Christianity with being a homosexual, as it is NOT a religion, but a choice. I have friends who are gay, and they will always be my friends, but I DO NOT support or encourage their lifestyle at all. Guess what? We are still friends. I don't want a bunch of pro-gay posters hanging on the walls of CHS, but that is not to say that gays should be disrespected at CHS. Kids are impressionable and think about the kids who are open about their alternative lifestyle...not a big deal to an educated adult, but to a 15 year old in a high school locker room, that may be a different story. Good job CHS board. "

lp wrote on Oct 23, 2009 2:51 PM:

" I used to think differently about gay/lesbian relationships, that it was wrong but until you have a child that is gay/lesbian You will think differently You can say how you feel now but when the shoe is on the other foot You think and feel a totally different way, because that's your kid and no matter what, you still love them
Come on people, this world is made up of so many different types of people We are all human ...bottom line "

asrgc wrote on Oct 23, 2009 2:45 PM:

" Better take down all the Christian club displays, sport displays, academic club displays, FFA, etc.!!!! They may confuse kids on what path in life to take for extracurricular activities, and you don't want a jock hanging with the science geeks! "

R wrote on Oct 23, 2009 2:40 PM:

" I'm upset with the Board of Education and the parents who got so bent out of shape. Are you all that scared of something you don't know about? Or just plain against a perfect live you live in. "

Grateful I dont have kids in that school wrote on Oct 23, 2009 2:39 PM:

" The number of people congratulating the school board's decision in this matter is truly disturbing. I guess it is simply more proof of just how intolerant this "nice small town" really is. "

Michael J. wrote on Oct 23, 2009 2:17 PM:

" Thank you, Corunna High School, for taking a stand against a political agenda. Let's give parents the right to be parents and the freedom to choose how to best present the gay and transvestite lifestyles to their children. "

CHS Grad wrote on Oct 23, 2009 12:37 PM:

" As a former Corunna graduate, I am appalled at the actions of the school board in regards to the issue of creating tolerance for the rights of homosexuals. How do you prepare our high school students to go out into the world beyond Corunna following graduation? What message are you sending that those individuals or families that live this lifestyle should not be tolerated? That is the kind of thinking that gets people hurt or killed.
Whenever you hold a public office, you must put your own personal views aside in order to be a voice for all members of your constituency. My understanding is that Member Lockwood gave a sermon that included the following:
”When I look at these monthly themes it is apparent to me that one does not choose to be a black man, or a woman, or Hispanic, or Latino. One would say that sexual preference is an orientation. One may have an orientation to shoplift and they even say god made them that way but we wouldn’t display it on a bulletin board. One may even have an orientation toward adultery and go as far as god made him that way but we would not condone that in a school setting. These individuals refer to themselves as an orientation. A black man doesn’t choose to be black, a tall white man doesn’t choose to be tall…these people have an orientation or choice for this lifestyle.” Wow, do we really believe that this is the type of representation we need from any public official in the year 2009? I believe that there is only one person who has the right to be this judgmental and that is God himself? It is not the right of anyone but God to make that judgment when the day comes.
Mr. Lockwood’s position on the board should not be a pulpit for his religious views. Is he suggesting that students of Corunna High School who will go out into a world that may have them working next to or for homosexuals should not be tolerant? Shame on you Mr. Lockwood and the board of Corunna Public Schools. You have given the good name of Corunna a black eye with your personal views on this matter. "

B wrote on Oct 23, 2009 12:12 PM:

" Keep up the good work Corunna! I appreciate folks standing against filth and immorality. "

Bill wrote on Oct 23, 2009 12:06 PM:

" Is there ANYTHING more pathetic than Heterosexuals demanding that the Gay children that HETEROSEXUALS THEMSELVES CREATED not be allowed to be represented at their schools???

Heterosexuals have reached an ALL TIME LOW. Even for Heterosexuals.

Stop abusing the gay children THAT YOU YOURSELVES ARE CREATING.

What kind of species treats their own offspring in such a despicable manner??? Ahhhh, yes. Only the Heterosexual.

Morality indeed, Heterosexuals. Morality indeed. "

Y wrote on Oct 23, 2009 12:03 PM:

" Yet another reason why suicide rates are so high among gay & lesbian youth. Keep quiet about it, pretend it doesn't exist and OMG if you mention you know all those kids will want to be gay. Ummm, last time I checked, that isn't how the world works. "

Jake wrote on Oct 23, 2009 11:44 AM:

" I bet this would be another issue entirely if they took down a poster suggesting that Christians and their lifestyle is not diseased. "

cn wrote on Oct 23, 2009 11:18 AM:

" I can honestly say i am disappointed... I do not support gay and lesbian relationships, however students have EVERY right to display ideas. Yes this is a contoversial topic, however come on these kids are all in High School I'm pretty sure everysingle student there knows someone who is gay, lesbian, or bi. it is not going to confuse anyone... "

Huh wrote on Oct 23, 2009 10:58 AM:

" What was the display actually of? "

justamomm wrote on Oct 23, 2009 10:57 AM:

" Stanley said the Diversity Club was created to promote tolerance, respect and discuss how to treat all groups equally recognizing that everyone is different. apparently gays and lesbians are not part of the group that needs acceptance?? i think the corunna school system is in denial about gay and lesbian teens at their school. my daughter graduated from there and had several gay friends. of course chs also thinks their kids arent out partyingand doin drugs either but they need to get over their holier than thou beliefs and face reality "

asrgc wrote on Oct 23, 2009 10:32 AM:

" Gasp! A gay and lesbian display in the school! What will others think! Might ruin the "perfect" image of Corunna Schools! Way to show the students who are gay and lesbian that you support them! Just like when you two were teachers...you were in there for yourself, not the students! "

JH wrote on Oct 23, 2009 10:22 AM:

" BRAVO! To the school board for the "right" decision and to the parents who complained. "

RC wrote on Oct 23, 2009 10:01 AM:

" Good! "