County logo

CORUNNA — Shiawassee County moved one step closer to becoming a Second Amendment “sanctuary” county Wednesday as commissioners voted 6-1 to advance a resolution affirming residents’ right to bear arms to today’s full board meeting, set for 5 p.m. inside the Surbeck Building, 201 N. Shiawassee St.

Commissioner Marlene Webster, R-District 1, voted against the move during the panel’s Committee of the Whole meeting Wednesday, citing troublesome language in the resolution that supports both the Shiawassee County Sheriff (Brian BeGole) and the Shiawassee County Prosecuting Attorney (Scott Koerner) “in the exercise of their sound discretion to enforce any and all constitutional firearm laws.”

“I strongly support Second Amendment rights and the Constitution, and I’m sure there are laws out there that are violating Second Amendment rights, but I think more core to the Constitution than the Second Amendment is the balance of power,” Webster said. “We have a system for appealing unconstitutional laws, and if there’s a law that’s unconstitutional, it has to go through the court system to be deemed so. I feel like giving that authority to local law enforcement puts an additional burden on them and frankly violates the Constitution.”

The Second Amendment sanctuary movement — which seeks to stop new gun laws — is led locally by Byron resident Anthony Tolbert, who serves as chairman of the Shiawassee County chapter of Michigan for 2A Sanctuary Counties, a Facebook group.

Tolbert said the formation of the group, as well as the push for Shiawassee County to become a Second Amendment sanctuary, was sparked by actions to limit Second Amendment rights in Virginia.

In April, Democratic Gov. Ralph Northam approved a “red flag” law that allows law enforcement to temporarily seize firearms from individuals deemed a threat to themselves or others. As the legislation worked its way toward passage, a widespread pro-gun movement ignited throughout the state and subsequently the nation, as various localities made vows not to enforce what some officials in those areas perceived to be “unconstitutional” gun laws.

Tolbert initially approached the Shiawassee County Board of Commissioners with the resolution to become a sanctuary county in January. To date, he has collected more than 700 signatures from county residents in support of the resolution, he said.

“While our liberal and progressive friends in this county assure us that our Second Amendment rights are not going anywhere, we can simply point to their mainstream politics to know this is simply not true if they were to get their wish,” Tolbert said during the public comment portion of Wednesday’s meeting. “Our current governor and attorney general, as well as the (democratic) party’s presidential candidates have called for things such as red flag laws, common sense gun laws, bans and outright confiscations. It is our intent to send a message to Lansing and anywhere else that may look to infringe on our God-given, constitutionally protected rights.”

Commissioner Dan McMaster, R-District 2, spoke in support of the sanctuary resolution Wednesday, noting he’s received several emails and phone calls from residents regarding the proposal since the topic was first discussed earlier this year. Further action on the resolution was delayed for several months due to COVID-19, he added.

“I know my truth,” McMaster said, “and some of my constituents may disagree with this and that’s their right, but by far the majority of the constituents in my district and this county support this (resolution). In my almost four years of public service, this will probably be the vote that I will be the most proud of, (the vote) I will remember the most.”

Board Chairman Jeremy Root, R-District 5, also expressed support for Shiawassee County becoming a Second Amendment sanctuary, citing the 45 counties in Michigan that have already approved resolutions.

“I don’t think we’re out in left field, I don’t think we’re radical, I mean, that’s more than half the state,” Root said.

“I think the freedom to bear arms is one of the most important rights that’s granted to us,” Root continued. “This simply just reaffirms that we trust in our sheriff, we trust in our prosecutor that they make sound discretion and that they enforce constitutional laws and will not enforce anything unconstitutional on any of our residents.”

Webster said if the resolution simply stated the board supports the Second Amendment, she could support it.

“When it says that we give discretion to the sheriff and the prosecutor to, and it’s worded differently in this new draft, but the intent, as Chairman Root just stated, is that they could use their discretion to not enforce laws that they believe are (unconstitutional), that’s where I feel this document violates the Constitution,” Webster said. “If a law is unconstitutional, it has to be taken in litigation to the courts and appealed through the courts and determined by the Supreme Court whether or not it is a constitutional law.”

(5) comments

DavidB

Does anyone reads comments? If so, seems like there should be some regarding this topic. So let’s see some.

Louise

Possessing a gun is not a god-given right. God has NOTHING to do with it! I do not believe that the board represents the majority when it essentially supports gun possession by violent or mentally impaired people. The commissioners have not right to tell an abused woman that her husband/partner can keep his gun despite the threats. I am beyond angry by this move and hope it is overturned in future.

MicroMan

You are showing your total ignorance of the U.S. Constitution. Ya must be one of those lunatic-liberals who doesn't believe in FACTS or TRUTH.

ggriffin

For all these folks who are bravely voting to affirm the existence of the Second Amendment, courageously standing for the sanctity of the Constitution, I ask them this - where is the vote to declare Shiawassee County a "sanctuary county" for the 15th Amendment guaranteeing the right to vote will not be denied or abridged? My guess is our courageous commissioners don't feel like the 15th Amendment (to name just one example) is under attack, but the 2nd Amendment is, so and needs special protection. If any of our brave commissioners who took this courageous stand wish to step forward and explain how the 2nd Amendment is in reality under attack, which and by what means government forces are coming to get your sacred guns, I'd love to hear about it. And while I'm waiting, feel free to explain how Shiawassee County is taking steps to make sure everyone who wants to vote can safely vote during the pandemic.

DavidB

I think the Argus Press is part of the problem, they are basically an "enabler" for this sort of stupidly to occur.

Why hasn't this been front and center, information provided in advance. Using the paper's search function there were 7 letters to the editor and two new articles contain the word "sanctuary" at the county in 2020. Nothing big and nothing in the form of an Editorial.

While the first reading vote occurred yesterday, no advance news article and for the final reading today a news article with a five hour warning. Very sad.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.